I don’t like being judged. I don’t like being criticized.
I have always thought of myself as somewhat of a perfectionist. I was hard on myself, and wanted things done ‘just right’. As time went on, I began to realize that just about everyone around me is a ‘perfectionist’ in their own unique way. Some with achieving perfect handwriting, perfect parenting, perfect relationships, or perfectly clean homes. Who doesn’t want perfection?
That is because Hashem created us that way! He created us “betzalmo” - “in His Image” – which is perfect! And He gave us a very perfect driving force within – our G-dly soul. So we will forever feel agitated – until we reach perfection, until that perfect space within us is nourished. And we will forever feel uncomfortable in an imperfect world – for deep within, we know it wasn’t meant to be this way forever.
When I used to whine to my mother as a child, “it’s not fair!!” She’d respond with a smile, “Yup, life’s not fair!” I remember clearly how much that concept bothered me. I think children know in their gut that an unfair world is not a reality that will exist forever.
So if I have an unrealistic wish to be perfect, it makes sense that it hurts when someone points out that I am not… It bugs me to be reminded that I am human! That I am not perfect.
It’s a funny thing, because on the one hand – G-d wants us to do incredibly huge things – like Him! He wants us to be G-dly! To spread light! To achieve great heights! Yet He made us human… and humans make mistakes… So as great as He wants us to be, He also wants us to remember how small we really are in His presence…
When people give constructive criticism with loads of love, respect, and with the full intention of helping me grow – I embrace it. It still is not easy to swallow – but I do appreciate the opportunity for growth.
“Cherish criticism, for it will place you on the true heights”, said Rabbi Sholom Dov Ber of Lubavitch.
Yet I have seen that criticism that comes without respect, reproof that is void of love and concern… can really hurt. My instinctive reaction? To judge right back…! “Who says you’re so perfect??? Who gives you the right to correct me?” I throw a tantrum in my mind.
My brain takes me on a trip, jumping between two types of feelings. From feeling painfully guilty for the actual mistake I had made that was just pointed out. To extreme irritation at the person pointing out my mistake.
Until Moshiach comes - “life is not perfect” - and people will say things the way they do, sometimes lacking tact and feeling.
Yet in truth – G-d has sent those harsh words my way for a reason: for my good.
Perhaps G-d is simply trying to remind me that I have lots yet to achieve. If arrogance is the most un-G-dly character trait, then a dose of humility is a priceless opportunity to welcome G-d in. My mistakes have been pointed out, to perhaps remind me that I am NOT PERFECT and I have a lifetime to work towards perfection. G-d’s greatness is infinite – so I really have forever and ever to unite with His perfection. G-d is protecting me from arrogance that may come from getting no criticism at all.
I can be thankful to all those who have pointed out my mistakes, for they keep me on my toes and remind me that there is more work to do. They remind me how small I really am. They help me stay motivated to strive higher, and deepen my relationship with Hashem and with others.
So to all those who have felt judged or criticized by me in the past – I am truly sorry for any pain I have caused you.
And for all those who have pointed out my mistakes – thank you for the reminder that I have more work to do.
Am I perfect? Certainly not! None of us are – and there’s no need to judge each other for that. G-d wants us to strive for perfection and for a perfect world - so let’s support each other with this seemingly impossible task.
We will never be bored of growing! We are taught that when Moshiach comes, we will go “mechayil el choyil” – from strength to strength. During that time there will always be new opportunities for growth, exciting content to learn, thrilling heights to reach, and refreshing goals to achieve.
I look forward to a time when we can celebrate each other’s accomplishments and support each other’s growth – with mutual respect and good-old teamwork.



“Can you imagine wearing a “kick me” sign on your back, and not being able to take it off?” That was one of the many moving lines that Tikvah Juni shared at last night’s Friendship Circle Garden Party that my brother and sister-in-law hosted. 
